300 (based on Frank Miller's graphic novels) was a wonderfully surreal and strangely alluring film - the Sin City graphical treatment actually worked this time round. I'm sure King Xerxes didn't look or act like that, but whatever... I'm sure there was more Spartan Pederasty going on behind the quaint wolf-boy narrative than was actually onscreen in the first half hour of the film, but whatever...
The intimate battle scenes were far more convincing than the cringe-worthy torsos of swarthy men bathed in 'Davidov - cool water, advert' rain, than that giggle-making Kamasutra of Leonidas' love-making scene, than the 'hands on the Leonides' shoulders' giggle-festival from old Xerxes. Yes, the audience were laughing at those painful scenes, and rightly so.
At times, it was embarrassing as a film; as a character structure, flawed and over-acted. Technically speaking it was about as historically inaccurate as any Hollywood interpretation has ever been such that I was eagerly expecting the American Cavalry to come rushing over the misty, backlit hills to save the day. The ending was very much like the ending of gay director Jarman's SEBASTIAN, but those arrows, right, sticking into Leonidas at the end were all parallel, i.e. they entered his body from the side, when clearly that final black mist of arrows soared into Spartan flesh FROM ALTITUDE. Maybe, as really happened, Leonidas was long dead even before the Persians used the traitor's path to surround the hardy Spartans - and this final shot was an allusion to that? Conspiracy theorists?
It's like with my dissatisfaction with Stallone's JUGDE DREDD ... if Leonidas commanded such respect from his 300 Spartan bodyguards would he necessarily have to shout so much to get their attention?
All that said, credit where credit's due, as an action film, edited with a wicked rapier, 300 rocked!
The real Spartan story should be a lesson to all creatives the world over battling against prejudice, jingoism and tyranny - write your story the way you want, so that, if you're lucky, centuries from now, yours will be the remembered tale. Write like you die tomorrow.
Long live written horrors.
Long live creative spirit.
Long live artistic freedom.
*punches the sky with the leather jock-strapped boys*
:)